Questions!!??

The first book in the Twilight Saga Series by Stephenie Meyer. Come here and talk about all things related to Twilight the book or movie. More information can be found on our main website.

Questions!!??

Postby shante » Sun Jan 03, 2010 12:11 am

I would be this under 21 questions in the games section, but its a bunch of them.
First of all, wasn't ALICE supposed to be the one to say "i could smell her across the feild." Not rose? (when they were in the baseball feild.)
Next, why didn't alice see bella's decision to leave the hotel to go meet james? and why did it take THEM [Alice and Jasper in particular] so long to get there?? Shouldn't that have been the first place they look? and how did EDWARD beat them there? THEY were already in phenoix with bella! ??? [ i mean, of course edaward had to be first, in order to save bella, :roll: but still.]
and how could they not HEAR her??
And how come edward didn't notice how "attached" victoria and james were? Because when they were leaving the field, he put his arm around her..?

:problem: :problem:
I LOVE MY AVATAR --FOUND BY THE AWESOME JO!!! Lol =)
User avatar
shante
Site Admin
 
Posts: 1474
Joined: Fri Sep 11, 2009 11:34 am
Cash on hand: 1,006.18
Bank: 550.00

Re: Questions!!??

Postby AJ Cullen » Sun Jan 03, 2010 9:09 pm

yes you are right it is supposed ro be Alice who says that
as for the others i dont have the answer
Image
Team Edward<3
User avatar
AJ Cullen
Vampire
 
Posts: 126
Joined: Tue Dec 15, 2009 5:24 pm
Cash on hand: 0.00
Location: Cuddling with Rob under the stars on a beach

Re: Questions!!??

Postby Bolero » Mon Jan 04, 2010 6:48 am

Okie dokie.

So the first one, yes, in the book it was Alice who said it, but in the film Rosalie said it, but I think it worked really well, because she sort of snarled it, said it with a vengance, and I think it would have worked either way.

Alice and Bella's decision, and this is just how I interpreted it - Alice would have been so preoccupied watching Victoria on behalf of Rosalie and Esme back in Forks and James' changing decisions she would have just missed Bella's decision. And it took so long for Alice and Jasper to get there, because if you look, as Bella leaves the hotel, it is evening, so the sun was still out, although when she reached the studio it was night. And they would have had to wait around for Edward, Carlisle and Emmett, as back up.

I'm guessing Edward beat them there because as soon as they arrived, Edward left, and Edward, as James put it, was "faster than the others."

As for hearing her on the phone, that baffles me. I think Meyer just didn't think about that when she wrote the book, because after all, she was only going to write Twilight as a single book.

As for the Victoria/James bond, it does mention somewhere in the book that Edward says he did pick up on their bond, but he just didn't realise the strength of it. In the film, it was made obvious that James and Victoria were mates, but the fact was just never vocalised by any of the characters.

Well, those are the conclusions I came to, anyway ;)
Image
|Siggie made by Fabi|Avatar made by Adri|I like this place, and could happily spend all my time here|
User avatar
Bolero
Cullen
 
Posts: 372
Joined: Thu Dec 17, 2009 11:27 am
Cash on hand: 176.41
Location: Roller skating in search of Carlisle and Esme...

Re: Questions!!??

Postby Isabell_Clair » Mon Jan 04, 2010 3:12 pm

Thanks Jelly! I have been trying to figure out why Alice didn't see Bella decide to leave the hotel. In the book Alice sees her decide to go after James on her own. That's why Bella had to be tricky with trying to get away. She had Jasper walk her to the bathroom instead of Alice.
Image
"... Make me forget how awful I am. Make me forget him. Make me forget my own name. Fight back!"
Bella, Eclipse ch.24
User avatar
Isabell_Clair
Elite Pack
 
Posts: 2968
Joined: Mon Sep 28, 2009 3:13 pm
Cash on hand: 260.18
Location: Macomb, MI

Re: Questions!!??

Postby fabi » Mon Jan 04, 2010 7:40 pm

The thing is that there are differences between the movie and the book. :think:

I think that the book doesn't say -for instance- that Edward arrived first at the ballet studio. I think he just says 'we took care of him', referring to all that happened with James there. There is no fight. So, if there is inconsistency in that detail is from the movie not from the book.

I agree with Jells, the comment at the baseball field about how Bella smells fits Rosalie quite well, and I also remember that kind of comment from Edward. Again, there are differences movie-book.
| Team Seth | Eric Northman fan |
Image
User avatar
fabi
Elite Pack
 
Posts: 1707
Joined: Mon Oct 26, 2009 11:22 am
Cash on hand: 80.27
Bank: 1,105.00

Re: Questions!!??

Postby shante » Tue Jan 05, 2010 11:55 am

Thanks guys =) :thumbup:
I LOVE MY AVATAR --FOUND BY THE AWESOME JO!!! Lol =)
User avatar
shante
Site Admin
 
Posts: 1474
Joined: Fri Sep 11, 2009 11:34 am
Cash on hand: 1,006.18
Bank: 550.00

Re: Questions!!??

Postby NaeBby10 » Wed Jul 14, 2010 9:22 pm

In the beginning of the movie when Bella first sees the truck, she opens the door and accidently hits Jacob in the leg lol. When seeing that, I thought that was just a part of Bella being clumsy. But my sis thinks that she wasn't suppose to do that becuz when Bella does it, it seems like Kristen is like genuinely sorry and not just "oh sorry". I don't kno, maybe we're reading too much into it. But if that really was an accident, Taylor played it off well.
Image
Team Krislor
User avatar
NaeBby10
Vampire
 
Posts: 101
Joined: Wed Jul 07, 2010 10:48 pm
Cash on hand: 58.15
Bank: 194.71
Location: On the private Island with Taylor [Lautner], sipping margaritas & dreaming of what could be.. =)

Re: Questions!!??

Postby Wolf Pack Shan » Wed Aug 04, 2010 10:42 am

I think it really worked out better that Rosalie said "I could smell her from across the field." Because it would have been as mean if Alice had said it, only because she's so kind.
Image
Made By Me
User avatar
Wolf Pack Shan
Newborn
 
Posts: 87
Joined: Mon Mar 15, 2010 10:52 pm
Cash on hand: 39.54
Location: Somewhere near La Push


Return to Twilight

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest